CRA_DR_Blue_V2.0.jpg
Intelicrunch_Banner_Header.jpg

When an Exhibit Can Make or Break a Motion to Dismiss a FCRA Claim


Under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, including exhibits to a motion to dismiss may convert the motion into a motion for summary judgment. Generally, there are exceptions to this rule, such as including as an exhibit a document that the plaintiff relied on in its complaint. The decision whether to include an exhibit in a motion to dismiss is a strategic choice that depends on individual circumstances. A recent decision, however, illustrates an opportunity when the decision whether to include an exhibit directly affected the court’s decision to deny a motion to dismiss. In this case, the court denied a motion to dismiss a Fair Access to Credit Act (“FCRA”) when, due to the absence of a credit report, it was forced to view the allegations in the complaint in the light most favorable to the plaintiff.

In Fleming v. Ginny’s, Inc., No. 3:20-cv-00284, 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 217736 (S.D. Miss. Nov. 20, 2020), the plaintiff filed suit against Ginny’s and Midnight Velvet, two retailers specializing in household and fashionable wares, alleging that they failed to conduct a reasonable investigation into alleged discrepancies in her credit report. The disputed entries were a series of monthly payments of $25 to each defendant. The plaintiff disputed these charges and argued that each account was closed and neither had a balance. FULL ARTICLE

© 2020  InteliCrunch.com

InteliCrunch is a free service provided by a collective of people who monitor the background screening industry and how events affect not only the people in it, but even more importantly, the real human impact the industry has on today's society.*All third party logos and / or images used on this website are the sole property and / or registered trademarks of their respective companies or copyright holders. Use of these logos, images or likenesses does not, in any way, imply the endorsement of InteliCrunch by any of the businesses, brands or individuals represented, their parent companies, officers, employees, partners, or affiliates. Any such usage is for informational / news purposes only.  Any / all articles, announcements, releases or third-party-authored content is / are linked back to the original "source"  and author credit given  Furthermore, InteliCrunch is not responsible for, and does not warrant the safety of any third-party links or sites to which any viewer may be directed from InteliCrunch.  InteliCrunch has made reasonable efforts to ensure that any news or informational links on the site are from "known and reputable"  sources / websites.